Unlike usas representative democracy, the athenian democracy was direct. The parthenon has become almost a byword for democratic. Fifthcentury athens is praised as the cradle of democracy and sometimes treated as a. In classical athens everyone had the right to vote on any issue that was before the state. As he describes more fully in a new book, democratic ancient greek city. What happens to democracy when it is applied to a society with a large dispersed population. A politician would present an issue and anyone who was there to hear the issue could vote. Hamzawy argues that if the naturalist, politician, scientist, architect, inventor, to an end because of america and becoming reformed and revolutions we know french, russia. Athenian democracy history bibliographies cite this for me.
The elitism of the athenians was perhaps intended by the founding fathers to be prominent in the us, but thankfully, the two parties system in place now is a big leap from what democracy used to be. This a well researched academic paper that traces ancient democracy and offers a detailed explanation of its similarities and differences with modern democracy. American vs athenian democracy the west in the pre. The key difference between a democracy and a republic lies in the limits placed on government by the law, which has implications for minority rights. Including a useful chronology and blibliography, this second edition has been updated to take into account recent research. Athenian democracy history bibliographies in harvard style. Compare and contrast american democracy and athenian. The citystate of athens and surrounding territory of attica was the first government to have a true democracy. Modernday democratic governments owe a lot to the democracy of ancient athens. In fact, the ancient athenian system closely resembled the american republic brought on by the founding fathers and some have even referred to it as oligarchy. American democracy is just sort of a shorthand way to refer to our style. And in athens, as in other democracies of the time, it turns out there were. Ancient greeces most famous export to this day is arguably democracy. Ancient athens was the first documented society to practice democracy while the iroquois confederacy was one of the first democratic systems on the north american continent.
In one of the classic books on athenian democracy published in 1957, the author claimed. Ancient greece first coined the concept of democracy, yet almost every major ancient greek thinkerfrom plato and aristotle onwards was ambivalent towards or even hostile to democracy in any form. The purpose of samons book is to compare ancient athenian and modern american democracy which, i agree, are similar enough to be compared 10 with n. Their governmental system wasnt designed for the enormous, spreadout, and diverse populations of modern industrialized countries, but even in their small communities see social order of athens, there were problems. How was democracy in ancient greece different from in the. Start writing about how are athenian and american democracy similar with this example essay. Compare athenian democracy to american democracy today. Pointing out the success of athenian democracy and the ideals that america was looking to model is a great is a great way to compare the two. Most american politicians and citizens of whatever political persuasion seem to agree.
Their reconstructions show us the complexity of a political ethos and cultural. How does athenian democracy differ from american democracy. Compare and contrast athenian democracy with american democracy. Our current system american govt athenian govt only men can be a part of the govt and vote judicial both were made up of every day athenian men women can vote.
Compare and contrast athens and athenian democracy bartleby. Much of what we know about athenian democracy has been built up over time by detailed and painstaking studies of institutions and procedure. One of the great masters of this type of work is the danish scholar mogens herman hansen, who has published dozens of hardnosed, empiricallyminded books and articles, most recently as head of the copenhagen polis centre. Other greek cities set up democracies, most following the athenian model, but none are as well documented as athens. Both forms of government tend to use a representational system i. American democracy is just sort of a shorthand way to refer to our style of government.
Athenian democracy vs american democracy pixelmasterdesign. Athenian democracy developed around the sixth century bc in the greek citystate known as a polis of athens, comprising the city of athens and the surrounding territory of attica, is one of ancient greek democracy, and is often described as the first known democracy in the world. This early attempt at a fair and equal government run by the citizenry was unprecedented, and it served as a model for all the democratic governments that came after it. Unfortunately, the majority of the american voters today have very little idea about what and who theyre actually voting for, despite or perhaps because of the media efforts. Ancient democracy vs american democracy democracy in. Although american and athenian democracy succeed under different size electorates, their mission is still the same. The ancient athenian greeks are credited with inventing the institution of democracy. So, athenian democracy was not our ideal of equal freedom and rights, but more like a select club, facilitated to some extent by a slave population and in addition only really made possible, many scholars argue, by athens control over a large and.
Athenian democracy was probably true democracy in that all citizens, that had the right to do so, gathered together at once in a public forum to decide and time themselves. Compare and contrast athenian democracy and modern democracy. Lessons of ancient greek democracy for the modern world the. In the 5th century bce, the athenian democracy was made up of a set of assemblies and courts staffed by people with very short terms some as short s a dayover onethird of all. Explaining how america wanted the same ideals as athenians, but with a stronger and more stable government sets up a clear comparison between the two. Well for starters athenian democracy was considered a true democracy while american democracy is hardly a democracy at all, but it all has to do with scale. It is a source for much of our modern conception of democracy, but it is also quite singular in many of its features.
The athenian democracy the athenian democracy, also known as the classical democracy, was a direct democracy, where people did not elect representatives, but participated actively and directly by voting on legislation and executive bills in their own right. The system of governing in the modern world known as democracy has a rich historical background that originated in athens, greece. Whats wrong with democracy from athenian practice to. Athenian democracy democracy in ancient athens home. Compare and contrast athenian democracy and modern. Fathers of the american constitution, and argues that ancient democracy. If he could be restored to life and brought to washington dc, would an athenian visitor feel at home, even among the marble columns and the neo. The fundamental distinction between ancient athenian democracy. Relevant examples are used and a student analytical approach is used to come up with a. Try searching on jstor for other items related to this book.
What was the problem with athenian democracy answers. Then you can start reading kindle books on your smartphone, tablet, or. Women, slaves, children, and resident aliens did not have citizenship and could not vote. Now although many may in fact say that the american democracy is the best, many do not know that america government is a derivative from athens very own government. Athens defeat by macedon in 322 began a series of alternations between democracy and oligarchy. But would an athenian indeed consider america to be a democracy. The democracy was inseparably bound up with the ideals of liberty and equality, the rule of law, and the direct government of the people by the people. Creating a more detailed comparison to twentyfirst century democracy, john zumbrennen makes connections to ancient athenian leaders representing the silent demos and describing how this is done in the united states, specifically during the bush administration shortly after the 911 terrorist attacks. Conventional accounts of classical athenian democracy represent the assembly.
But obers work is not rooted in some timeless american tradition. The athenian democracy is one of the more intriguing aspects of political history. Athenian democracy is similar to modern democracies in that it grants a broad portion of the public a say in governance. We are used to thinking very highly of democracy and by extension, of ancient athens, the civilisation that gave rise to it. Samons has written an original and very provocative book. From athenian practice to american worship paperback april 23, 2007.
Enter your mobile number or email address below and well send you a link to download the free kindle app. Legislative made the laws the boule and the ecclesia comparing and contrasting. In ancient athens, people physically came together at an assembly and each persons vote counted towards the verdict. Use is made of archeology, comparison with other societies, the location of. Of course, the levels of ignorance couldve been low because the number of voters was also low in comparison to today, but more on that later. The book offers plenty of insight for readers interested in athenian history, but the provocative, perhaps brilliant, critique of modern american democracy promised at its outset gets lost along. Democracy hardcover paul cartledge oxford university. Why socrates hated democracy the book of life is the brain of the school of life, a gathering of the best ideas around wisdom and emotional intelligence. How did athenian democracy differ from contemporary. Athenian democracy was not only direct in the sense that decisions were made by the assembled people, but also the most direct in the sense that the people through the assembly, boule and courts of law controlled the entire political process and a large proportion of citizens were involved constantly in.
Was ancient greek democracy better than todays american democracy. I would argue that athenian democracy cannot be considered democratic at all, and so the difference between contemporary democracy and athenian government is enormous. Anyone studying pericles, greek democracy or 5th century greece should consider studying kagans book pericles of athens and the birth of democracy if you are not already. It is important to understand how democratic processes began and to comprehend the relationship between modern democracy and ancient athenian democracy. In a republic, a constitution or charter of rights protects certain inalienable. The larger the electorate, the more people can vote. Even though low voter turnout is still occurring in the us, the electorate is still big enough to require a representative democracy to ensure that every citizen has a voice. Alienation of political power was absurd to the greek people.
The good thing about democracy in ancient athens was that there was a lot less voter ignorance. Athenian democracy vs american democracy free essays. Athens and sparta were two powerful citystates, different from each other where athenian democracy focused on economic advancement, while sparta oligarchy focused on military force. This point may be named wolinian for the american political theorist.
It holds a wealth of information and is an invaluable resource in the ancient history classroom. Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. Athenian democracy developed in the late 6th century bc following reforms of ep. In this important book sher gives us a liberal perfectionist theory of the good. Athens democracy developed during the sixth and fifth centuries and. We like to think we live in a democracy but an ancient athenian might beg to differ. Compare and contrast athens and athenian democracy 971 words 4 pages. America, alongside many nations, recently celebrated the 2500th anniversary of the invention of democracy in ancient athens and its links with todays democracies in america and around the globe. Was ancient greek democracy better than todays american. Democracy vs republic difference and comparison diffen.
Of course, every student of political science knows that the american system of. Athenian vs american democracy the west in the pre. During the 40 annual meetings of the ekklesia, any of the roughly 40,000 male citizens of athens was allowed to appear and. Read this essay sample on in what ways is athenian democracy similar to american democracy. Athenian democracy, where citizens voted directly on issues placed before them in the.
Is the city state the only kind of state in which true democracy can exist. Regular citizens were invited to participate in these events. They did not have any influence on the government at this time. Ancient democracy vs american democracy, 2015 your bibliography. American democracy through ancient greek eyes by strauss. What are other examples of democratic societies besides athens. Each specialist in the history of ancient athenian democracy will presumably have a. Fifthcentury athens is praised as the cradle of democracy and sometimes treated as a potential. Athens democracy developed during the sixth and fifth centuries and continued into the fourth. In athens, all citizens were allowed to vote as long as they were educated, male, and over the age of 18. In what ways is athenian democracy similar to american. How is athenian democracy similar to american democracy. Athenian democracy started developing at the beginning of the 6th century bc. Basically, the citizens of athens voted for the legislative acts themselves rather than the people who implemented these acts.
Athenian democracy vs american democracy home athenian democracy vs american democracy 20200430 20200430 tagged athenian democracy vs american democracy youtube lesson 1. Peter lohrbach american representative democracy and athenian democracy undoubtedly had their similarities. Athenian democracy vs us democracy flashcards quizlet. The voters were indeed more knowledgeable, partly because of the.
1277 1084 624 1272 842 1490 1339 879 252 1347 953 1369 591 869 358 730 1063 748 734 1231 1568 100 820 1471 179 359 981 1280 1015 247 1180 461 689 865 421 1346